Skip to content

Scientists may have found why most of us learn to love coffee despite hating it as kids. A gut-to-brain dopamine signal teaches the brain to like flavours that come with a reward, and the researchers think caffeine works the same way

Most people remember their first sip of black coffee. It’s usually a grimace, followed by a firm decision never to try it again. Yet years later, many of those same people can’t start the day without a cup.

A new study suggests part of the reason lies in a slow conversation between the gut and the brain. Scientists at the University of California, San Francisco, have identified a dopamine signal that helps the brain learn which flavours are worth coming back to.

Born to dislike bitter

Humans are born with a natural dislike of bitter tastes. Many poisonous plants taste bitter, so steering clear of them would have helped our ancestors survive. That’s one reason children often reject coffee, dark chocolate and many green vegetables.

Yet tastes clearly change. Adults learn to enjoy foods they once avoided, and scientists have long suspected that the brain links a flavour to what happens after we eat or drink it. The question was how that learning happens.

Two kinds of dopamine

Dopamine is a chemical messenger involved in motivation, reward and learning. It’s best known for fast bursts that happen when we see or taste something rewarding, part of the brain’s reward system.

The new study, published on 4 November in Nature, looked at a slower dopamine pathway that responds to signals from inside the body. Unlike the quick bursts triggered by what we see and taste, this signal builds over several minutes as food reaches the gut.

Tracing the signal in mice

Physiologist Zachary Knight and his team delivered sugar water or a milkshake-like liquid directly into the stomachs of mice. This let them separate the effects of nutrients in the gut from the taste in the mouth.

They found that nutrients in the gut triggered a sustained release of dopamine in a part of the brain called the basolateral amygdala, especially on the left side. The amygdala is often linked with emotions, but it also helps the brain judge the value of things in the world.

Switching learning on and off

The team then tested whether this signal actually controls learning. When they blocked it, the mice still ate normally but failed to learn that a new flavour meant calories.

They also ran the experiment in reverse. When they artificially stimulated the same dopamine pathway after mice tasted a calorie-free flavour, the mice came to prefer it, even though it gave them no nutrition. In effect, the scientists had taught the mice to like a flavour by recreating the gut’s reward signal.

Signs of the same system in people

The researchers also looked for similar activity in humans. A reanalysis of an earlier brain scan study of 13 men, along with a new scanning study of 38 adults, found nutrient-linked activity in the same brain region.

These human studies are small, and they show a matching pattern rather than proof that the pathway works the same way in people. But they suggest the system found in mice may also exist in us.

Where coffee comes in

The experiments didn’t test coffee or caffeine. The coffee connection comes from Knight, who suggested that once the brain links the taste of coffee with the lift from caffeine, the drink begins to taste better.

That’s a reasonable idea, but it’s still unproven. Caffeine isn’t a nutrient, and the study focused on calories from sugar and fat. Other factors also shape our love of coffee, including its aroma, habit, repeated exposure and the social rituals around it. The same learning process may help explain why many people develop a taste for chocolate and rich, fatty foods.

Knight has suggested that understanding this pathway could one day help people adjust their food preferences, perhaps making healthier foods more appealing. For now, the research offers a satisfying explanation for something many of us have experienced. That first bitter sip may have been unpleasant, but over time, your brain may have quietly learned to look forward to what came after it.

From around the web