Skip to content

Faking a smile over and over can leave you feeling worse, not better. In an experiment with about 1,200 people, one forced smile gave a tiny mood lift, but repeated forced smiles left people less happy and more irritated

Picture a supermarket cashier near the end of a long shift. A customer snaps at them about a price, and they smile anyway. Then they smile at the next customer, and the next, because the job requires it.

For years, psychology suggested that smiling, even when you don’t feel like it, can make you a little happier. A new study suggests the story is more complicated. One forced smile may help a little, but being made to smile again and again can leave people feeling worse.

The idea that smiling makes you happy

The idea that your face can change your feelings goes back more than a century. It became famous in 1988, when a German study had people hold a pen in their teeth, forcing their face into something like a smile. They rated cartoons as funnier than people who held the pen in their lips.

Later attempts to repeat that study had mixed results, and the idea became controversial. Psychologist Nicholas Coles, now at the University of Florida, spent years studying it. His research, including a large international project, found that posed smiles can make people slightly happier, but the effect is small.

A study built on real life

Coles had worked in customer service himself, and he noticed that the research didn’t match his own experience. Smiling because a manager tells you to doesn’t feel the same as choosing to smile in a lab. So he and his colleagues designed an experiment that looked more like a real job.

They recruited 1,201 people for an online study, and 1,174 were included in the final analysis. Participants looked at either pleasant pictures, such as kittens and flowers, or unpleasant ones, such as theft and animal mistreatment. Some were told to smile, while others let their faces react naturally. Some smiled once, and others had to repeat it 10 times.

Adding pressure

To mimic workplace pressure, the researchers warned half the participants that they could lose $2 of their $6 payment if they didn’t smile properly. After each task, everyone rated how happy they felt.

The results showed a clear pattern. When people looked at unpleasant images, one posed smile gave a small boost in happiness, even with the money warning. But repeating the smile weakened that benefit, and repeating it under financial pressure wiped it out completely.

When smiling backfired

The results were even more striking with the pleasant pictures. A single smile made little difference there. But people who had to smile repeatedly, or under pressure, ended up less happy than those who simply reacted naturally.

They also reported more irritation and anger. Coles said that forcing one smile without pressure can lift mood a little, but making it more like the real world, with repetition and penalties, completely reversed the effect. The study was published on 1 October 2026 in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology.

Why forced smiles can wear you down

Psychologists have a name for managing your emotions as part of a job: emotional labour. The term was popularised by sociologist Arlie Hochschild in her 1983 book about flight attendants, who were expected to stay cheerful whatever happened on board.

Research on emotional labour has found that “surface acting”, showing an emotion you don’t feel, is linked to stress and burnout. Constantly hiding your real feelings takes effort, and over time that effort can leave people drained. The new study adds experimental evidence that repeatedly forcing a smile, especially under pressure, can make people feel worse in the moment.

What this means for the rest of us

The study doesn’t mean smiling is bad. A genuine smile, or even a single deliberate one on a hard day, may still give a small lift. What seems to matter is whether the smile feels like your choice or an obligation repeated again and again.

For workplaces, the findings raise questions about rules that require staff to look cheerful at all times. For everyone else, they are a reminder that it’s fine not to feel happy every moment. As Coles has suggested, chasing constant happiness can be less useful than simply allowing yourself to feel what you feel, and smiling when it comes naturally.

From around the web