Skip to content

Psychology says people who grew up before smartphones learned a skill most of us are quietly losing: being bored. It matters more than it sounds, because the brain does some of its most creative work when it has nothing else to do

Think back to a long car journey as a child, before phones and tablets. The view out of the window, the same few songs on the radio, hours with nothing to do. You probably remember the feeling well: boredom, slow and heavy.

Today, that feeling rarely lasts more than a few seconds. A queue, a waiting room or an ad break is instantly filled by a phone. But psychologists have found that those empty moments may matter more than they seem, because a bored, wandering mind is often a creative one.

A boring experiment with a surprising result

In 2014, psychologists Sandi Mann and Rebekah Cadman at the University of Central Lancashire set out to test whether boredom could make people more creative. In their study, they asked volunteers to do something deliberately dull: copy out numbers from a telephone directory for 15 minutes.

Afterwards, everyone was asked to think of as many uses as possible for a pair of plastic cups, a common test of creative thinking. The people who had spent time copying numbers came up with more ideas than those who had skipped the boring task.

The duller the better

The researchers then made the task even more passive. One group copied numbers, while another simply read them. The readers, who had the least to do, came up with the most creative ideas of all.

Mann suggested the reason is daydreaming. When a task is boring and requires little effort, the mind starts to drift, and that drifting appears to help people make new connections. Writing the numbers kept people slightly more focused, leaving less room for their minds to wander.

Why a wandering mind helps

Another study backs this up. In 2012, psychologist Benjamin Baird and his colleagues at the University of California, Santa Barbara gave people a creativity task, then a 12-minute break. Some did a demanding task during the break, some did an easy one, some rested and some had no break at all.

Only the people who did the easy, undemanding task improved when they tried the creativity test again. They also reported the most mind wandering. The researchers concluded that simple activities that let the mind drift can help with creative problem-solving.

The brain’s background network

When we stop focusing on the outside world, the brain doesn’t switch off. A set of connected regions, often called the default mode network, becomes more active. It includes parts of the cingulate cortex and areas linked to the hippocampus, which helps with memory.

This network is involved in daydreaming, remembering the past, imagining the future and making unexpected connections between ideas. Many scientists think it plays an important role in creativity, though how exactly it works is still being studied.

We don’t like being alone with our thoughts

The trouble is that most people find empty time uncomfortable. In a 2014 study published in Science, psychologist Timothy Wilson and colleagues at the University of Virginia asked people to sit alone with their thoughts for up to 15 minutes, with no phone or other distractions.

Many found it unpleasant. In one experiment, participants could give themselves a mild electric shock during the thinking period, even though they had earlier said they would pay to avoid it. Two-thirds of the men and a quarter of the women shocked themselves at least once, apparently preferring pain to doing nothing.

Making room for boredom again

People who grew up before smartphones had little choice but to sit through long, empty stretches of time. Whether that made them more creative hasn’t been directly tested, and plenty of people now find other ways to let their minds wander. But the research suggests something has been lost when every quiet moment is filled.

Bringing some of it back doesn’t require giving up your phone. It might mean leaving it in your pocket in a queue, taking a walk without headphones, or letting your thoughts drift while doing the washing-up. These moments may feel unproductive. But, as the research suggests, they may be exactly when your brain does some of its best and most creative work.

From around the web