Imagine you have 30 minutes free and three people to choose from to spend it with: a close family member, the author of a book you’ve just read, or someone you’ve just met who seems to share your interests. Who would you pick?
When psychologists asked this question, older adults overwhelmingly chose the family member. Younger people were more likely to pick the new acquaintance or the author. The reason, research suggests, has less to do with age than with how much time people feel they have left.
The theory behind the shift
Stanford psychologist Laura Carstensen developed an idea called socioemotional selectivity theory to explain this. It says that how we spend our time depends on how much future we think we have.
When the future feels long, as it usually does when we’re young, people focus on exploring, learning new things and meeting new people, because those investments may pay off later. When time feels more limited, people shift towards what feels meaningful now, such as close relationships and positive experiences.
It’s about time, not age
The most striking evidence is that this pattern can be reversed. In one study, older people were asked to imagine that a medical breakthrough would give them 20 more healthy years. Their preference for familiar people largely disappeared, and their choices looked more like younger adults’.
The opposite also happened. When younger people imagined they were about to move far away, they chose familiar partners too, just like older adults. In Hong Kong, researchers found that two months before the 1997 handover to China, a period of uncertainty for many residents, younger people also began to prefer familiar social partners. A year later, the difference between age groups had returned.
Real-life reminders of time
Researchers saw similar shifts after major events. During the SARS epidemic in Hong Kong in 2003, and after the September 11 attacks in the United States, younger people’s social preferences temporarily resembled those of older adults.
More recently, a study by Carstensen and colleague Da Jiang found the COVID-19 pandemic reduced age differences in social preferences too. When life feels fragile, people of any age tend to turn towards the people who matter most to them.
Why it can look like not caring
To outsiders, this shift can look like apathy. An older relative may lose interest in office gossip, skip social events with acquaintances, or show little enthusiasm for new trends. They may seem less bothered by things that once upset them.
But research suggests this is often a change in priorities, not a loss of feeling. Older adults also tend to pay more attention to positive information than negative, a pattern psychologists call the positivity effect. Brain studies have found that the amygdala, which helps process emotions, responds differently to positive and negative images in older adults than in younger ones.
The paradox of ageing
This may help explain what researchers call the paradox of ageing. Despite facing more health problems and losses, many older adults report being as happy as younger people, or happier. Their emotional lives often become more stable.
By focusing on what matters most, and letting go of what doesn’t, many people find more satisfaction in later life. Carstensen’s research suggests this isn’t simply resignation. It’s a sensible response to a changing sense of time.
What we can all learn from it
You don’t need to wait until later life to benefit from this idea. Carstensen’s experiments show that simply imagining your time is limited can change what you choose, and that can be a useful exercise at any age. Ask yourself who you would want to spend a free afternoon with if you knew such afternoons were running out. The answer is usually clearer than expected.
Then go back to the opening choice: the family member, the author or the new acquaintance. None of them is the wrong answer. But the next time an older relative chooses the familiar face over the new one, or shrugs off something that once would have upset them, it’s worth seeing it for what it often is. They haven’t stopped caring. They’ve simply worked out where their care is best spent.