Skip to content

After Vogel and Bogen's full commissurotomies at White Memorial in Los Angeles for epilepsy, early 1960s tests found patients' mute right hemisphere could pick an object described only as 'a measuring instrument', while the speaking left had no idea.

Network map of connections within and between the two hemispheres of the human brain
Lateral and top views of the human brain's connectivity backbone, with both hemispheres visible from above. Photo: Hagmann P, Cammoun L, Gigandet X, Meuli R, Honey CJ, Wedeen VJ, Sporns O via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

A patient hears a spoken phrase. No object is named. A hand finds the right object by touch anyway. Then follow-up questions put to the patient in words show that the talking side of the brain knew nothing about it.

That pattern is set out in Roger Sperry's Nobel lecture, given on 8 December 1981 at Karolinska Institutet in Stockholm, where it was read by Professor David Ottoson because of Sperry's poor health.

The relevant sentence is short. "Correct tactual retrieval by the right hemisphere was achieved for objects not directly named but only described with complex spoken phrases like 'a measuring instrument', 'container for liquids', etc.," the lecture says.

The people tested were epilepsy patients. According to the lecture, they were patients of the neurosurgeons Joseph Bogen and his chief, Philip Vogel (spelled Phillip in Sperry's lecture) of the White Memorial Medical Center in Los Angeles, and they had undergone a midline surgical section of the corpus callosum and other forebrain commissures in a last resort effort to control severe, intractable epilepsy. Sperry describes the operation as having "severed all neural cross connections for direct communication between the two hemispheres".

Here is the question those tests opened up in the early 1960s. If one half of a brain can act correctly on a spoken description while the other half reports knowing nothing of it, what is the relationship between the two halves?

Sperry calls the result "a considerable surprise". The reason is the doctrine he spends the opening of the lecture laying out. Years of lesion evidence, up through the 1950s into the early 1960s, had built a picture of a dominant left language hemisphere and a minor right one that was taken to be "wordblind", word-deaf, mute, agraphic, and "lacking generally in higher cognitive function".

What the early studies with Michael Gazzaniga appeared to show instead was a right hemisphere that was neither word-deaf nor word-blind. Lateralized testing found it largely mute and agraphic, but able to comprehend, at a moderately high level, words spoken aloud by the examiner.

Because that hemisphere was largely mute, its answers had to be shown some other way. In the reading tests, where printed words were flashed to the left visual field, Sperry writes that comprehension was "demonstrated manually in each case by selective retrieval or by pointing to corresponding objects or pictures in a choice array". The "measuring instrument" result sits in the same run of findings, as tactual retrieval of an object that was described rather than named.

The claim that the answers came from the right side rested on a procedural check. In these lateralized testing procedures, Sperry writes, "the speaking left hemisphere could be shown, by follow-up verbal questions, to have remained incognisant or quite unaware of the answers and performances being ascribed to the right hemisphere".

Stated plainly in the lecture: "The speaking hemisphere in these patients could tell us directly in its own words that it knew nothing of the inner experience involved in test performances correctly carried out by the mute partner hemisphere."

That cut so hard against contemporary neurological doctrine that one of the surgeons withdrew his name from the first language papers. "So strong was contemporary neurological doctrine to the contrary in the early sixties that Dr. Bogen felt obliged in good conscience to withdraw his name from our initial papers on language," Sperry writes.

The surgical backstory is filled in by Gazzaniga, who ran the first human tests as a Caltech graduate student and later wrote a retrospective for Nature Reviews Neuroscience. "Philip Vogel and Joseph Bogen carried out a complete commissurotomy on a former paratrooper who was experiencing severe and life-threatening seizures," he writes. During surgery they completely severed all cortical commissures, which was successful in controlling that patient's seizures. Gazzaniga's timeline dates the operation to 1962, and dates the adaptation of animal testing techniques for the new human series to 1962 through 1967.

Gazzaniga's own account of the turning point is a singular memory: "that of the moment when I discovered that case W.J. could no longer verbally describe (from his left hemisphere) stimuli presented to his freshly disconnected right hemisphere."

None of this was the first attempt to split a human brain for epilepsy. Gazzaniga's timeline records that Van Wagenen and Herren performed the first known callosotomy operations in humans in 1940, intended to control seizures in patients with intractable epilepsy. Those surgeries did not lead to a reduction in seizures and the pair stopped performing the procedure.

Their patients were studied by A. J. Akelaitis at the University of Rochester in the 1940s. In Gazzaniga's summary, "he concluded that the disconnection of the two hemispheres did not result in any cognitive or behavioural effects".

So a conclusion of no effects sat in the human literature while animal work pointed elsewhere. Studies of split-brain rats, cats and monkeys by Sperry and colleagues, Gazzaniga writes, "resulted in the development of more sophisticated techniques with which to directly assess the function of each hemisphere independently". He states the puzzle in his own words: "Akelaitis claimed that, in humans, severing the corpus callosum has none of the dramatic effects seen in animals. How could this be?"

His answer is hedged, and he leaves both halves of it open. "Akelaitis got it wrong, probably because his tests were not sophisticated enough and/or his patients did not have complete callosal sections." The surgical half has a pedigree of its own, since Vogel and Bogen had speculated that the earlier operations were unsuccessful because the corpus callosum had not been fully severed. Across the gap between the Rochester work and the Los Angeles series, the record offers testing method and surgical completeness side by side, without settling which mattered more.

Sperry himself warned about where the finding was heading in popular terms. In the same lecture he writes that "the growing wave of semipopular extrapolations and speculations concerning 'leftbrain' vs. 'right-brain' functions call for a word of caution", and that the left-right dichotomy in cognitive mode "is an idea with which it is very easy to run wild". He adds that in the normal state the two hemispheres appear to work closely together as a unit, rather than one being turned on while the other idles.

The separation was also not total in the commissurotomy patients Sperry's group tested later. Sperry reports that the more structured and specific informational components of cognitive processing remained confined within the hemisphere in which they were generated, "whereas the emotional overtones leaked across to influence neural processing in the other hemisphere", and that subtle shades of emotion or semantic connotation generated on the right "could be quite helpful to the left hemisphere in its efforts to guess the nature of a stimulus known only to the right hemisphere". Gazzaniga notes that despite cortical disconnection the two hemispheres are connected through subcortical pathways, and that in some cases there is evidence for interhemispheric integration.

Nor did the result settle what the right hemisphere can do with language. Sperry calls the issues raised controversial and says the answers "are still not entirely resolved". He sets out the objections to his own reading: that the commissurotomy evidence may be misleading because of "an atypical bilateral spread of language into the right hemisphere correlated with the long-term epilepsy and associated pathology", and that a further criticism "has invoked individual variation in view of the small patient group involved".

Those are the limits to carry away. The patients had long-standing severe, intractable epilepsy before any surgery, critics pointed to associated pathology, there were few of them, and the "measuring instrument" line appears in a lecture written about two decades after the tests, offered as an example of the kind of phrase used rather than as a method section. Trial counts and procedures have to come from the original reports, starting with the 1960s reports Sperry cites, including Gazzaniga and Sperry's 1967 paper in Brain.

One idea folded backwards into the early 1960s belongs later. Gazzaniga's timeline credits the concept of a left brain "interpreter", which creates a schema or "story" about events "that goes beyond the actual available information", to his 1978 book with J. E. LeDoux. That is a later interpretation.

The early-1960s finding is narrower and stranger than the pop version that later grew up around split-brain work. In a small series of people whose hemispheres had been surgically disconnected, one half of a brain understood a description well enough to find the object, and the half with the words, asked directly, had nothing to report.

Citation: Gazzaniga, M. S., Bogen, J. E. & Sperry, R. W. Some functional effects of sectioning the cerebral commissures in man. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 48, 1765-1769 (1962). Quoted material from Roger W. Sperry, "Some Effects of Disconnecting the Cerebral Hemispheres," Nobel Lecture, 8 December 1981, and Michael S. Gazzaniga, "Forty-five years of split-brain research and still going strong," Nature Reviews Neuroscience 6, August 2005.

Sources:

From around the web